The Newest Threat to the Great Whales: Seismic Blasting and Military Sonar
Updated: Sep 8, 2020
Article by GWC's board member and scientific advisor, Lenard Milich, PHD.
Imagine the loudest sound you might possibly hear. How about going to see a rocket launch? That would have been, for the Space Shuttle, approximately 120 decibels (dB, a measure of sound intensity) 3 miles from the launch site. If you would have been unfortunate enough to be in the vicinity of the atom bomb dropped on Hiroshima, well, sound meters placed just 100 meters from a nuclear bomb test site registered a peak of 210 dB. The intensity of the sound alone would be enough to kill a human being, so if the bomb doesn't kill you, the noise will. Krakatoa, the volcano that erupted in 1883 between the islands of Java and Sumatra in today’s Indonesia, and which caused extreme winters for the next four years: 180 dB, a blast that could be heard in Australia, 1930 miles away.
Doctors place 115 dB as the threshold at which hearing damage occurs.
So, having put a relative scale on this, consider that seismic exploration surveys, undertaken in the mad search for yet more climate-destructive fossil fuels, generate the loudest human sounds in the ocean short of standing right next to an explosive, can reach more than 250 dB, and be heard for miles — most probably, across entire ocean basins. The low frequency sounds generated by seismic airguns, commonly below 200 Hz in frequency, have been recorded at locations up to 4,000 km from the source, and can ‘blanket’ areas of up to 300,000 km2 with noise. Generally, the dominant frequencies of seismic airguns overlap with those of the communication signals of baleen whales (10 Hz–1 kHz).
These blasts can and certainly do cause hearing loss in marine mammals, disturbing essential behaviors such as feeding and breeding, mask communications between individual whales, and obviously if the whales are nearby, cause massive concussive damage, severely damaging their hearing and pounding their bodies with a sound wave that, sadly, in many cases, will be unsurvivable.
The inner ear of cetaceans works in the same way as that of terrestrial mammals. The differences lie in the inner ear characteristics. The major differences are the number of auditory ganglion cells, the ratio of the number of ganglion cells to the number of hair cells, the size of the auditory nerve, the size of the basilar membrane, and the support of the basilar membrane. Toothed whales have more ganglion cells associated with hearing than terrestrial mammals. Baleen whales have fewer nerve cells associated with hearing compared to toothed whales, but more than terrestrial mammals. Cetaceans also have a lot more ganglion cells associated with each hair cell than do humans and a much larger auditory nerve. All of these adaptations mean that cetaceans engage in more complex auditory processing than do we humans. Unlike humans who learn to use sign language if deaf, whales do not have this option. Damage to these sensitive cilia and nerves will have profound negative consequences. Compromised hearing – a sense so crucial for the whales’ survival – almost assuredly results in their death.
Moreover, cetaceans’ middle ears, like ours, are air-filled. So, loud sounds – which can be thought of as being an intense pressure wave – can cause what is medically termed barotrauma. Significant barotrauma is often associated with permanent complications such as hearing and balance deficits. Imagine being a whale with damaged balance! Furthermore, such intense sounds are likely to have other detrimental physiological effects: human divers exposed to sounds louder than 154 dB in low-frequency ranges are reported to have experienced changes in their heart rates or breathing frequency.
Naval sonar, which can retain an intensity of 140 dB as far as 300 miles from their source, is another threat to the great whales. Evidence shows that whales will swim hundreds of miles, rapidly change their depth (sometime leading to bleeding from the eyes and ears), and even beach themselves to get away from the sounds of sonar. But unlike the beaked whales that in August 2020 started beaching on European shores, most individuals among the great whales will sink once dead, so we simply do not know of the toll that seismic surveys and naval sonar take on them. One thing is clear, though, which is that these pulsating sounds seem to be driving whales away from where they may be located. If this is from one of their feeding grounds, once again the consequences for their survival are grim.
Indeed, the US Department of the Interior’s own studies estimate that seismic proposals now under review would cause more than 31 million instances of harm to marine mammals in the Gulf of Mexico and 13.5 million harmful interactions with marine mammals in the Atlantic, killing or injuring 138,000 dolphins and whales — including an estimated nine endangered North Atlantic right whales, of which there are only about 400 remaining. And that’s only off the Eastern coasts of the United States. These blasts are occurring globally, unfortunately, many in prime great whale breeding areas or migration routes.
The Great Whale Conservancy joins with other NGOs concerned about this latest threat to the planet’s whales, both baleen and toothed. Contact your local representatives to register your dismay about the concussive sounds deluging ocean basins, and call for a halt to unnecessary climate-destructive searches for yet more fossil fuels.
Where are seismic blasts taking place? Unfortunately, globally.
Center for Biological Diversity, undated. Seismic Surveys for Oil. https://www.biologicaldiversity.org/campaigns/seismic_blasting/ [accessed August 27, 2020].
Hoare, P., 2020. Beached whale increase may be due to military sonar exercises, say experts. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/aug/24/beached-whale-increase-may-be-due-to-military-sonar-exercises-say-experts [accessed August 27, 2020].
Kavanagh, A.S. et al., 2019. Seismic surveys reduce cetacean sightings across a large marine ecosystem. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-55500-4 [accessed August 27, 2020].
Mann, L, 2011. Loud Noises. https://www.dallasobserver.com/music/loud-noises-the-very-short-list-of-things-that-are-actually-louder-than-dallas-mavericks-fans-7069258 [accessed August 27, 2020].
Mora R. et. Al., 2011. The Effect of Sonar on Human Hearing. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/221916150_The_Effect_of_Sonar_on_Human_Hearing [accessed Aug 27 2020].
O’Neill, O.J. et al., 2020. Middle Ear Barotrauma. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK499851/ [accessed August 27, 2020].
Scientific American, 2009. Does Military Sonar Kill Marine Wildlife? https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/does-military-sonar-kill/ [accessed August 27, 2020].
Stocker, M., 2013. A foot in the door on seismic airgun surveys. https://ocean-noise.com/2013/06/a-foot-in-the-door-on-seismic-airgun-surveys/ [accessed August 27, 2020].
University of Rhode Island, undated. Hearing in Cetaceans and Sirenians, the Fully Aquatic Ear. https://dosits.org/animals/sound-reception/marine-mammals-hear/hearing-in-cetaceans/ [accessed August 27, 2020].